The Best Dog Toys for Teething Puppies: What to Look For
By Pet Products, Supplies & Accessories - Petmate Store | Published: 2026-08-30
Category: Buying Guides
Discover what makes a chew toy safe and effective for teething puppies, plus tips on materials, sizes, and rotation to keep your pup happy.
Teething is a natural phase in a puppy's life, usually beginning around 3-4 months and lasting until they are about 6-8 months old. During this time, puppies experience discomfort as their baby teeth fall out and adult teeth come in. This leads to increased chewing, which can be destructive to your furniture and shoes, but it's also essential for their dental health and development.
Choosing the right toys can make a world of difference. Not only do they provide relief, but they also redirect your puppy's chewing to appropriate items. In this guide, we'll explore what to look for in teething toys, including materials, size, and durability, and we'll highlight a few products that can help.
Key Features of Teething Puppy Toys
When selecting toys for a teething puppy, the most important factor is the material. Look for toys that are soft enough to be gentle on sore gums but durable enough to withstand sharp puppy teeth. Rubber and silicone are excellent choices because they provide a satisfying chew and can be chilled for extra relief. Avoid toys with hard plastics that could crack and cause injury, and steer clear of toys with small parts that could be swallowed.
Size is another critical consideration. A toy that is too small can be a choking hazard, while one that is too large may be difficult for your puppy to hold and chew. As a general rule, choose a toy that is larger than your puppy's mouth but not so big that it's unwieldy. Always supervise your puppy during play, especially with new toys, to ensure they are using them safely.
- Look for toys labeled as 'puppy-safe' or 'for teething'.
- Consider chilling rubber toys in the freezer for extra soothing relief.
- Rotate toys every few days to keep your puppy interested.
Top Toy Types for Puppy Teething Relief
There are several types of toys that work well for teething puppies. Chew toys are the most obvious choice, and they come in various shapes and textures. Some have ridges or nubs that massage the gums, which can be particularly soothing. Dental toys often have a textured surface that helps clean teeth as your puppy chews, promoting good oral hygiene.
Interactive toys, like puzzle toys, can also be beneficial. They not only provide a chewing outlet but also engage your puppy's mind, reducing anxiety and boredom. You can stuff these toys with treats or peanut butter to encourage chewing. However, always choose treats that are safe for puppies and avoid overfeeding.
- Rubber chew toys with raised bumps can massage gums.
- Puzzle toys with treat compartments keep puppies busy and mentally stimulated.
- Avoid toys with strings or ribbons that can be ingested.
How to Choose the Right Chew Toy for Your Puppy
Every puppy is different, so it's important to observe your puppy's chewing habits. Some puppies are aggressive chewers and will destroy toys quickly, while others are gentler. For aggressive chewers, look for extra-durable toys made from tough rubber or nylon. For gentler chewers, softer rubber or plush toys may be sufficient, but always check for any loose parts.
You should also consider your puppy's breed size. Larger breeds will need bigger, stronger toys, while smaller breeds can manage with smaller, softer ones. The Petmate E-Z Load Two Door Dog & Cat Kennel is a great option for crate training, but for chew toys, the JW Gripsoft Cat Nail Clipper is not suitable for chewing—it's for grooming. Instead, focus on toys like the Arm & Hammer Bone Dispenser & Cornstarch Waste Bags, which is a dispenser, not a chew toy. For actual chewing, look for dedicated chew toys like the Wild Eats Braided Paddywack, which is a natural chew treat that can be soothing for teething puppies.

- Match the toy's durability to your puppy's chewing strength.
- Consider breed size when selecting toy size and strength.
- Natural chews like braided paddywack can be a good alternative to synthetic toys.
Safety Tips for Teething Toys
Safety should always be your top priority. Always inspect toys regularly for signs of wear and tear, such as cracks, holes, or loose pieces. If a toy is damaged, replace it immediately to prevent your puppy from swallowing small parts. Also, avoid toys that are treated with harmful chemicals or have strong odors, as these could be toxic.
Supervise your puppy when they are playing with any toy, especially new ones. This will help you catch any potential issues early. Additionally, it's a good idea to have a variety of toys on hand so you can rotate them, keeping your puppy engaged and preventing boredom. The Petmate Heavy Duty Storage Bin is an excellent way to store and organize your puppy's toy collection, making it easy to switch toys out and keep them clean.
- Inspect toys before each play session.
- Replace worn-out toys immediately.
- Use a storage bin to keep toys organized and clean.
Choosing the right toys for your teething puppy can make this challenging phase easier for both of you. By focusing on safe, durable materials, proper sizing, and variety, you can provide relief and prevent destructive chewing. Remember to supervise playtime and regularly inspect toys for damage. With the right selection, your puppy will happily chew through this stage and develop healthy habits for life.



