Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-13 Pet Products, Supplies & Accessories - Petmate Store 0 views

Mad Cat Olive Meowtini vs Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker

Mad Cat Olive Meowtini vs Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker

Compare the Mad Cat Olive Meowtini and Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker on materials, cat attractants, and play style to pick the right toy for your cat.

A quick look at two Mad Cat toys

The Mad Cat Olive Meowtini and the Mad Cat Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker are both one-size cat toys from Mad Cat, but they differ in materials, attractants, and how they invite play. The Meowtini is a plush toy filled with a blend of catnip and silvervine plus a crinkle sound, while the Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker is made of natural wool with no seams, stitching, or stuffing. Neither toy comes with supplied preparation or operating instructions, so your cat's reaction will guide how you use them. This comparison focuses on what the catalog tells us—and where details are missing.

What the Meowtini offers

  • Mad Cat Olive Meowtini: Filled with a custom blend of tempting catnip and silvervine for twice the cat attractants, plus a fun crinkle for enticing sound. The dual attractants may appeal to cats that don't respond to catnip alone, and the crinkle adds auditory interest.
    Mad Cat Olive Meowtini
    Mad Cat Olive Meowtini
  • Mad Cat Olive Meowtini: Each toy is made of soft, high-quality plush with multiple textures. Multiple textures can encourage batting, kicking, and cuddling, making it a versatile choice for different play moods.
  • Mad Cat Olive Meowtini: Silvervine is an all-natural catnip alternative that cats love, it elicits a similar reaction to catnip and works for many cats who normally are not affected by catnip. If your cat ignores catnip, the silvervine in this toy may still spark interest.

What the Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker offers

  • Mad Cat Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker: Mad Cat Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker are made of natural quality wool that are biodegradable, with no seams, stitching, or stuffing. The seamless wool construction means there are no stitched edges or stuffing to come loose, which may suit cats that chew or shred toys.
    Mad Cat Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker
    Mad Cat Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker
  • Mad Cat Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker: Roll or toss with the customer combo of catnip and silvervine for the ultimate play experience. This toy is designed to be used with catnip and silvervine that you add yourself, letting you control the intensity and refresh the scent.
  • Mad Cat Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker: These Wacky Wool toys are unique shapes and materials that entince your cat to engage those natural instincts of batting, chasing and pouncing! The shape and wool texture are intended to trigger active play, making it a good fit for energetic cats.

Key differences at a glance

The biggest difference is how each toy delivers attractants. The Meowtini comes pre-filled with a catnip and silvervine blend, while the Wacky Wool Kicker is a wool toy that you pair with your own catnip and silvervine. That means the Meowtini is ready to use out of the box, whereas the Kicker requires you to supply the attractants.

  • Material: Meowtini: soft plush with multiple textures. Wacky Wool Kicker: natural wool with no seams, stitching, or stuffing.
  • Cat attractants: Meowtini: pre-filled with catnip and silvervine blend. Wacky Wool Kicker: no built-in attractants; designed to be used with your own catnip and silvervine.
  • Sound: Meowtini: includes a crinkle for enticing sound. Wacky Wool Kicker: no crinkle mentioned in the catalog.
  • Play style: Meowtini: great for tossing, batting, kicking, and cuddling. Wacky Wool Kicker: encourages batting, chasing, and pouncing.
  • Biodegradability: Wacky Wool Kicker: wool is biodegradable. Meowtini: not specified in the catalog.

Which toy suits your cat?

If your cat is highly active and loves to chase, bat, and pounce, the Wacky Wool Crinkle Kicker's wool texture and shape may be a natural fit. Its seamless construction also makes it a sensible option for cats that are tough on plush toys. Because you add your own catnip and silvervine, you can adjust the scent level or skip it entirely if your cat isn't interested.

For cats that enjoy a mix of textures and respond to catnip or silvervine, the Olive Meowtini offers a ready-to-use option with a built-in crinkle sound. The plush material also makes it suitable for cuddling after play. If your cat has shown no reaction to catnip, the silvervine in the Meowtini may still get a response, according to the catalog.

What the catalog doesn’t tell you

Neither toy has supplied care instructions, so you'll need to use your judgment for cleaning. The Wacky Wool Kicker is wool and biodegradable, but the catalog doesn't specify whether it can be washed. The Meowtini's plush material may require spot cleaning, but again, no instructions are provided. Similarly, there are no sizing details beyond "one size," so it's best to supervise your cat during play, especially if your cat is a strong chewer. Finally, the catalog doesn't state how long the catnip or silvervine scent lasts in the Meowtini, or whether it can be refreshed.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile