Pet Products, Supplies & Accessories - Petmate Store

Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky: Natural Chew Buying Guide

Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky: Natural Chew Buying Guide

By Pet Products, Supplies & Accessories - Petmate Store | Published: 2026-11-04

Category: Product Reviews

A practical buying guide to the Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky, including who it suits, how to size it, and when a different natural chew makes more sense.

Quick answer

Choose the Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky if you want a long-lasting, jerky-wrapped natural chew for a dog that enjoys working on a single piece. Skip it if your dog loses interest in hard chews quickly or needs a softer, faster treat.

What the jerky wrap changes about the chew

The slow-roasted steak wrap gives the chew an immediate, flavorful start before your dog reaches the buffalo tail underneath. That matters for dogs that sniff a plain natural chew and walk away: the jerky layer rewards the first few minutes of chewing and can make the whole piece more appealing.

The trade-off is that the jerky layer wears off first. Once it is gone, your dog is left with the buffalo tail, which is a different texture and may not hold the same interest. If your dog is picky about plain chews, watch the first session to see whether the tail keeps them engaged.

Size and chew style: match the piece to the dog

This chew comes in size options, so the right choice depends on your dog's mouth and chewing style rather than breed alone. A piece that is too small can be swallowed too quickly; one that is too large may be awkward to hold and get abandoned.

The catalog does not list a chew-strength rating or a recommended dog weight range for this product. Treat that as a decision limitation: if your dog is a powerful chewer or a gulper, supervise closely and choose the larger size rather than assuming the chew will last a set number of minutes.

Where this chew fits in a treat routine

Because the product is described as high in protein and low in fat, it can work as an occasional longer chew rather than a quick training reward. Keep it for calm downtime, a crate settle, or a supervised evening chew instead of using it to reward fast recalls.

The gluten-free and grain-free formulation may matter if your household already avoids those ingredients in treats. It does not make the chew appropriate for every dog, and it does not replace your veterinarian's advice for a dog with a diagnosed food allergy.

Decision rules for buying this chew

  • When to choose it: Pick the Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky if your dog already enjoys natural chews and you want a single piece that starts with a jerky coating and continues as a buffalo tail chew.
  • When to size up: If your dog tends to swallow treats whole or chews aggressively, choose the larger size option and supervise the first session. Do not rely on the chew as a substitute for a chew toy. Check the piece against your dog's mouth before leaving them alone with it.
  • When to choose something else: If your dog is a puppy, a senior with fragile teeth, or a dog that gives up on hard chews quickly, a softer or shorter-lasting treat is a better fit. This chew is not marketed as a puppy or senior-specific product.

Product facts

  • Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky: Made from free-range, grass-fed water buffalo and wrapped in slow-roasted steak jerky; gluten-free, grain-free, high in protein and low in fat. The jerky wrap offers a flavorful start, while the buffalo tail provides the longer chew underneath.
    Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky
    Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky

Who this chew suits

Best for

  • Adult dogs that enjoy working on a long-lasting natural chew
  • Owners looking for a grain-free, gluten-free chew with a jerky start

Not for

  • Puppies or dogs with fragile teeth that need a softer chew
  • Dogs that lose interest in plain natural chews after the coating is gone

Shop Related Products

Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky

Wild Eats Water Buffalo Tail With Jerky

$5.50 $10.99

Shop Now