My puppy carries this thing around all day now. The shaker rattles just enough to keep her interested without driving me nuts, and it doesn't leave marks when she bats it across the hardwood.
Adam E.★★★★★
The chenille fabric is soft enough that my puppy carries it around even when we're not playing, and it hasn't picked up a single snag on our hardwood. Best part is how quiet it is when she shakes it at 11pm.
Elizabeth★★★★☆
The chenille fabric is soft enough that my puppy carries it around like a security blanket, and the shaker sound keeps her interested way longer than her other toys. It's a bit louder on my hardwood floors than I'd like, but that's honestly the only downside.